Ep. 24: When You’re Attracted to Someone Other Than Your Spouse: What to Do Next

Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Pandora

When You’re Attracted to Someone You Shouldn’t Be

If you're listening to this episode and it feels uncomfortably close to home, I want you to hear this first: you are not the only one. This is a topic that hits home for more people than we'd like to admit, but almost no one raises their hand and says so out loud. They struggle in silence, and silence is exactly where shame and secrecy do their best work. That's why I wanted to talk about it. This whole thing is a poisonous plant that grows best in the dark, so let's flip on the light.

Here's the overarching assumption I'm bringing to this conversation: your marriage, however imperfect it is (and all of ours are), is still an irreplaceable gift. The benefits of marriage compound over the long haul, financially, emotionally, and in the people we become for having stuck it out and learned to love each other well. Marriage itself — as long as it’s not marked by abuse, coercive control, or ongoing/unhealed infidelity — count on do a remarkable job of stabilizing us and helping us flourish as people.

But the era of history that we live in doesn’t always make it easy to grow a lasting, thriving connection, or to keep our heads on straight about our marriage. We've been trained to believe that what feels good to us is what's best for us, and that anything hard must be wrong. But hard doesn't equal bad. Hard often signals something worth fighting for. When we drift toward whatever makes us happiest in the moment, our judgment gets cloudy, and when someone comes along who makes us feel seen, heard, or beautiful, it's easy to assume that feeling is a sign we're supposed to follow it.

I explain why your heart will steer you wrong here: novelty and romantic excitement flood us with dopamine, like the pull of a slot machine, while long-term love shifts toward the deep, bonded warmth of oxytocin. Fading butterflies are normal and expected. They're not a verdict on your marriage. (And if you want more thrill and dopamine in your marriage, start by making a commitment to kiss each other passionately for 30 seconds every day. It helps enormously.)

In this episode we talk about both the internal and external work you’ll need to do to safeguard your marriage and get yourself back out of the mental danger zone.

Internally

  • Refuse to keep comparing your spouse to this other person, especially for the qualities your spouse doesn't have

  • Pay that person less attention in your thoughts, not more, and remind yourself that they have flaws too, and that they would let you down in ways every bit as disappointing as your spouse does now

  • Remember that the secret ingredient in a great marriage isn't finding the perfect partner. It's learning to work with what you've got, over and over, every single day

Externally

  • If you haven't told the person you're attracted to them, don't. If they do know, make clear that things are changing

  • Cut off any contact or behavior you wouldn't do in front of your spouse, including texting, long one-on-one conversations, and meeting up without your spouse knowing

  • Go further and cut off anything that looks innocent but is driven by a disproportionate desire to see them or be noticed by them. There is no safe dosage when your heart is in that place

  • Build friendships with people who are safe to confide in

  • Get curious about what drew you in, and give yourself and your spouse the chance to make things right. Ask yourself the hard question: what have I done to contribute to this dynamic?

  • Bring in a couples therapist if you need one, and have the hard conversations about what you long for

I close with a daily challenge: list ten things you admire and are grateful for in your spouse. What you focus on grows, and gratitude gets us out of the fight-flight-freeze of the amygdala and back into the prefrontal cortex, where we make our best decisions and operate as our wisest selves.

Timestamps

  • 00:28 Why this topic matters (and why silence makes it worse)

  • 01:16 The overarching assumptions of this episode

  • 03:53 "If it feels good, it must be good": the cultural lie

  • 06:46 Dopamine, oxytocin, and why your heart can steer you wrong

  • 08:55 You have to starve it

  • 10:51 Internal work: stop the comparison

  • 14:35 External work: safeguard your marriage and your heart

  • 15:36 Cutting off the contact you wouldn't have in front of your spouse

  • 17:46 Giving your marriage the chance to make it right

  • 20:20 The ten-things gratitude challenge

Resource mentioned: Not Just Friends by Dr. Shirley Glass

This podcast is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional counseling or therapy.

Next
Next

Ep. 23: Changing How You Think About Your Marriage